SEA OF MILK
- Neutral Milk Hotel was an American indie folk band. The band's chief lyricist and songwriter, Jeff Mangum, played with a number of other musicians on the band's two full-length albums. Notable contributors to the band's oeuvre include Jeremy Barnes (drums), Scott Spillane (horns), Julian Koster (banjo/bass guitar/saw) and producer-instrumentalist Robert Schneider. Neutral Milk Hotel is a part of The Elephant 6 Recording Company, based out of Athens, Georgia.
- There is a bit of an indescribable quality to the brilliance of Neutral Milk Hotel’s "In the Aeroplane Over the Sea". It’s one of those albums that people will either love or hate, to be honest. There isn’t much of a middle ground because if someone feels repulsed by Jeff Mangum’s unique vocal style, then the whole album will be marred in his eyes. For some, enjoying Mangum’s vocals will take time, but personally, it only took a couple listens before I thoroughly enjoyed them.
- Neutral Milk Hotel, eh? What a strange band name, and look at that album cover. It’s someone with…well what is it? A tambourine maybe for a head? And they’re waving? Great stuff. Anyway, I’m looking at that and thinking that this must be something which is really really weird.
- Well, maybe it is, but when it starts off with some simple acoustic chords and the voice comes in to sing over the top of it, you realise that this doesn’t sound at all complex. It isn’t an illusion either. Almost the entire album is made up of a voice and some chords, with various backing instruments used. So seriously people, what is the big deal? I mean, all I can play on the guitar is the G chord and the E minor chord, but I feel like I’m already on my way to playing these songs just as good if not better than this guy. How good can an album be if it’s just some guy and his guitar? Surely you need a solo or some really complex stuff right? Well, this might just be the ultimate example of a master songwriter at work. It might be easy to play but it ends up still being like nothing I’ve ever heard before.
- This album is extremely personal. Some people absolutely love it and some people just don’t see what the fuss is about. Those who don’t see what the fuss is about are fully entitled to their opinion. Some of the album’s biggest fans might say that these people just don’t know art or that they only dislike it because they don’t understand it. I’d be acting like “The Fool” though if I did the same. They can’t see what the fuss is about, so who cares? They can like what they want. Reviewing this album is kind of a pointless exercise. Great, I’ve said that only after I’ve written 390 words (thanks word count). What I mean is that if I write a review praising it, the other people who love it will read it and think: ‘oh yes! That describes the album perfectly!’ On the other hand, those who can’t understand the fuss will be like: ‘what the hell man? It sucks!’ That leaves those (un?)lucky people who are yet to discover it.
- I could tell you about how I liked In The Aeroplane Over the Sea on the first listen, and then became almost obsessed with it on the second listen. I was walking around all day with my head acting almost as a Neutral Milk Hotel jukebox, rotating all the songs on the album around and playing each one. I was trying to concentrate on what someone was saying but all I could think of was ‘but then they buried her alive/one evening 1945/with just her sister at her side…’ Then when that finished, another song on the album would start. Now how cheesy does that sound?
- I could tell you about how it took me ages to actually enjoy any other music at all after this. Almost everything seemed to pale in comparison. I even listened to “Too Drunk to Fuck” by the Dead Kennedys without laughing, because all I was thinking about was ‘Daddy please hear this song that I sing/in your heart there’s a spark that just screams…’ Everything seemed so inferior and it took a bit of time to get over that. No doubt this is actually turning you away from the album because what I’m saying is so clichéd and stupid.
- I could tell you about how this album is more emotional than almost anything else out there. It is at times heart-wrenching, at times depressing, and at times uplifting. ‘The sun it is passed/now it’s blacker than black/I can hear as you tap on your jar/I am listening to hear where you are…’ Am I getting weird stares yet?
- I could even tell you about how yesterday I read a news story about a 16 year old girl with leukemia, who knows that this Christmas is going to be her last. Still though, you see her smiling and stating her wish to enjoy the rest of her life as much as possible. All I was thinking of was ‘and one day we will die/and our ashes will fly/from the aeroplane over the sea/but for now we are young/let us lay in the sun/and count every beautiful thing we can see’. I think that if I forced it a little I could have cried.
- Put it down. Let it go. Perhaps if you get the album too, then you might love it as well. Who knows, you might come and join me and the rest of them as we get out our guitars and serenade the night away while standing in our cheese-filled paradise. Sounds like something out of a Neutral Milk Hotel album.
‘Say what you want to say
And hang for your hollow ways
Moving your mouth to pull out all your miracles…’
Track-List in the Comments
More info about Neutral Milk Hotel